Over 80% of businesses now use internet-based phone systems, and the market for them is set to hit $150 billion by 2028. A while back, I was helping my sister’s small catering business figure out how to handle their calls. They needed something cheap and easy, but we got stuck choosing between a softphone and a traditional VoIP setup. It felt like picking between a smartphone and a landline—both worked, but which was better for them? That’s when I started digging into what these systems really do, and it opened my eyes.
Softphones and traditional VoIP both let you make calls over the internet, but they’re built differently, cost different amounts, and suit different kinds of teams. Getting this choice right can save you money and keep your team running smoothly. In this article, I’m going to walk you through what softphones and traditional VoIP are, how they compare, and how to pick the one that’s best for your crew. Picture us chatting over lunch, sorting out the details to find what’ll keep your team talking without a hitch.
Read More: How to Build an Effective IVR Call Center Workflow
What Are Softphones and Traditional VoIP?
Let’s start by getting a handle on what these two things are. I used to think all internet phone systems were pretty much the same, but softphones and traditional VoIP each have their own way of doing things. Knowing the difference helped me figure out what might work for a team like my sister’s.
Softphones: Your Phone as an App
A softphone is basically an app you put on your computer, phone, or tablet to make calls over the internet. Think of apps like Zoom Phone or Microsoft Teams—it’s called “soft” because there’s no actual phone, just software. You grab a headset, open the app, and you’re calling. It’s all based on VoIP tech, but it uses the devices you already have, which makes it super handy.
When I first used a softphone for a freelance gig, I couldn’t believe I could call clients from my laptop while sitting in my living room. It was so easy, but I wondered if it could keep up with a whole team’s needs.
Traditional VoIP: The Classic Desk Phone
Traditional VoIP uses physical phones—the kind you see on office desks—but they connect to the internet instead of old phone lines. Brands like Cisco or Yealink make these phones, and they come with a VoIP service that offers stuff like voicemail, call transfers, or group calls. It’s internet-powered but feels like the phone systems you’d find in a big office.
My sister’s catering business thought about traditional VoIP because they liked the idea of “real” phones on their desks, but the price tag made them pause.
How They Stack Up
To choose between a softphone and traditional VoIP, you need to know how they’re different. When I was helping my sister, we looked at things like cost, setup, flexibility, and features to make sense of it. Here’s what we found.
Cost: Cheap Start vs. Bigger Spend
Money’s usually the first thing you think about. Softphones are easy on the wallet because you don’t need to buy any equipment. You just download an app, and most charge $10-$30 a month per person. Some, like Google Voice, even have free versions for basic stuff.
Traditional VoIP means buying actual phones, which can run $50-$300 each, plus setup and upkeep costs. The monthly fees are about the same as softphones, but those upfront costs can hurt, especially for a small business. My sister’s team saved a ton by going with a softphone since they didn’t have to buy phones for everyone.
Setup and Upkeep: Quick Start vs. More Work
Setting up a phone system can feel like a headache. Softphones are dead simple—you download the app, log in, and you’re ready to call. Updates happen on their own, and there’s no gear to mess with. I got a softphone running for my own calls in less than 15 minutes, no sweat.
Traditional VoIP takes more effort. You’ve got to set up the phones, hook them to your internet, and sometimes call in a tech person to sort out wiring or glitches. Keeping them working can mean fixing or replacing phones, which adds up. For a big office with a tech team, this might be fine, but smaller groups like my sister’s preferred the no-fuss softphone.
Flexibility: Go Anywhere vs. Stay Put
Teams today need to stay connected, whether they’re at the office, home, or on the go. Softphones are awesome for this because they work on any device with internet. You can take a call on your phone at a park or your laptop at a coffee shop. I once handled a client call from a friend’s couch using a softphone, and it was seamless.
Traditional VoIP is stuck to those desk phones, so it’s not as easy to move around. You can sometimes send calls to your cell, but it’s clunky. If your team’s mostly in one place, traditional VoIP might work, but for folks who work from different spots, softphones are hard to beat.
Features and Growth: Tech-Savvy vs. Solid Basics
Both systems give you stuff like voicemail, call forwarding, and video calls, but they shine in different ways. Softphones often tie into other apps, like your email or team chat tools, which is great if you use a lot of tech. They’re also easy to grow with—just add more users without buying anything extra.
Traditional VoIP phones are super reliable, with clear calls and extras like intercoms or call waiting, which are great for busy offices. Growing means buying more phones, though, which can get pricey. My sister’s team loved how their softphone worked with their scheduling app, but a dentist’s office nearby stuck with traditional VoIP for its dependable call quality.
Why Pick a Softphone?
Softphones have some big wins that make them a favorite for a lot of teams. I’ve seen them make life easier for small businesses and people working from home. Here’s why they might be your team’s choice.
Saves You Money
Since you don’t need to buy phones, softphones are a lot cheaper to start with. This is perfect for new businesses or solo workers. My sister’s catering crew saved thousands by skipping hardware.
Works Anywhere
Softphones let you call from wherever you are, as long as you’ve got internet. This is a lifesaver for teams spread out or on the move. I’ve taken calls from all sorts of places, and it’s always worked like a charm.
Connects with Your Tools
Lots of softphones link up with stuff like your calendar or customer tracking system, which can save time. This was a big deal for my sister’s business—they could see client info right in the app.
Why Go with Traditional VoIP?
Traditional VoIP has its own strengths, especially for teams who want a steady, professional setup. Here’s why it might be the way to go.
Clear, Reliable Calls
Desk phones usually sound better, which matters if you’re on calls all day, like in a doctor’s office or law firm. A clinic I know picked traditional VoIP because they needed every word to come through crisp.
Looks Professional
Having actual phones on desks can make your business feel more legit, which some clients like. A realtor friend said their VoIP phones gave their office a polished vibe.
Built for Busy Teams
Traditional VoIP often has features like call menus or multi-line support, which are great for places with lots of calls, like customer service desks.
How to Pick What’s Best for Your Team
Choosing between a softphone and traditional VoIP comes down to what your team needs. Here’s a simple plan I came up with after helping my sister and poking around this topic.
Step 1: Check Your Budget
Look at what you can spend now and each month. If you’re short on cash, a softphone’s lower startup cost is a win. If you can spend more upfront, traditional VoIP might be worth it for the long haul.
Step 2: Think About How Your Team Works
Are you all in one office, or are people working from home or traveling? Softphones are great for moving around; traditional VoIP fits teams who stay put. My sister’s remote team went with softphones, but their lawyer’s office liked VoIP phones for their in-person setup.
Step 3: List What You Need
Want your phone system to work with other apps? Softphones are often better for that. Need super-clear calls or special call features? Traditional VoIP might be the pick. Write down what’s non-negotiable for your team.
Step 4: Try Before You Buy
Lots of softphone apps offer free trials, and some VoIP companies let you test their phones. Give one a spin to see if it feels right. Start with a few users and add more as you go.
Stories That Bring It to Life
To show you how this works, here are a couple of stories I’ve heard about businesses using these systems. They’re not just ideas—they’re real examples of what’s possible.
A Freelance Team’s Softphone Win
A group of five freelance designers picked a softphone app like 3CX. It was cheap at $12 per person a month and let them call clients from their laptops or phones, no matter where they were. They saved big compared to buying phones and loved how it tied into their project software.
A Retail Store’s VoIP Choice
A 15-person retail store went with traditional VoIP for its reliable calls and professional look. The $150-per-phone cost was a stretch, but features like call waiting helped their busy front desk. It fit their in-store needs perfectly.
Tackling Your Questions
You might be thinking: which one’s really the best? I wondered that too when I was helping my sister. Here’s how softphones and traditional VoIP handle the stuff you’re probably worried about.
Will Calls Sound Good?
Softphones need a strong internet connection to sound clear, and a bad signal can make things choppy. Traditional VoIP phones are more dependable, especially if your internet’s wired. I’ve had softphone calls glitch on weak Wi-Fi, but VoIP phones usually sound solid.
Are They Safe to Use?
Both use security tricks to keep calls private, but softphones rely on your device’s safety, so you need good passwords and updates. VoIP phones are tougher to hack since they’re separate devices. Look for systems with strong call protection.
Can They Grow with My Team?
Softphones are super easy to expand—just add more users. Traditional VoIP means buying new phones, which can cost a lot. My sister’s team added three softphone users in a snap, but a VoIP-based office took weeks to get new phones set up.
Conclusion: Pick the System That Works for You
I used to think choosing a phone system was just about finding the cheapest option, but digging into softphones and traditional VoIP showed me it’s about what keeps your team connected and happy. Softphones are affordable and let you work from anywhere, making them great for small or scattered teams. Traditional VoIP offers clear calls and a professional feel, perfect for offices with lots of calls or a need for reliability. It’s all about finding what fits your crew.
Give this a try: jot down what your team needs—cost, flexibility, features—and look at a softphone trial or VoIP demo. Your team’s calls are too important to guess at, so take a small step to find what works. You’ll be glad you did.
FAQs
Q: Do softphones sound as good as VoIP phones?
A: With great internet, softphones are close, but VoIP phones are more reliable for heavy call days.
Q: Are softphones safe for business?
A: Yep, if your devices are secure and the app uses call protection. VoIP phones are a bit harder to mess with.
Q: How much does traditional VoIP cost?
A: Phones are $50-$300 each, plus $10-$30 a month per user. Softphones skip the phone cost.
Q: Can I switch systems later?
A: Sure, lots of providers offer both, so you can change if your team’s needs shift.